FT	New York City FC	5-4	Toronto FC
13		0 - 1	Jesús Jiménez
28		0 - 2	Jesús Jiménez
38	Valentin Castellanos	1 - 2
HT		1 - 2
49	Thiago Andrade	2 - 2
54	Santiago Rodríguez	3 - 2
58	Keaton Parks	4 - 2
75	Gabriel Pereira	5 - 2
86		5 - 3	Deandre Kerr
89	Alfredo Morales	5 - 3
90		5 - 4	Michael Bradley
FT		5 - 4